We buy and field-test every product we review. Independent & reader-supported — we earn commissions on some links. Full disclosure.
The Database · 24 products · One rubric

Every tick repellent, scored the same way.

No vibes, no category mercy: each product below is scored on the same published rubric — efficacy evidence (40%), duration (25%), skin & gear experience (20%), value (15%). Products we've worn through Connecticut field seasons carry a ★ badge; the rest are label-and-literature scored and say so. Filter away.

Tier 1 · Proven Tier 2 · Conditional Tier 3 · Not supported ★ Field tested
24 of 24 products
9.6/ 10

Ranger Ready Picaridin 20% — Scent Zero

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 20%8–12 hrs★ Field tested

Our best-overall pick: full-trail-day protection, genuinely zero odor, fine-mist trigger, and it never touched our sunglasses or shell fabrics. The field benchmark everything else gets measured against.

9.3/ 10

Sawyer Permethrin 0.5% Fabric Spray

Tier 1 · ProvenClothing treatment · 0.5%~6 washes★ Field tested

The classic clothing treatment — kills ticks on contact with treated fabric and performed identically to Ranger Ready's version in our testing. Buy whichever is cheaper the day you order.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
9.3/ 10

Ranger Ready Permethrin 0.5% Fabric Spray

Tier 1 · ProvenClothing treatment · 0.5%~6 washes★ Field tested

Trigger-bottle permethrin, same active and concentration as Sawyer, same contact-kill result on our treated pant legs and socks. Tied score, deliberately.

9.3/ 10

Sawyer Picaridin 20% Continuous Spray

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 20%8–12 hrsLabel + literature

Same Tier-1 active and concentration as our top pick in a widely available spray. Scored from label and published data; rotates into our next field season.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
9.2/ 10

Ranger Ready P2 Pak (Picaridin + Permethrin)

Tier 1 · ProvenClothing treatment · 20% + 0.5%Trip-length system★ Field tested

The two-layer strategy in one box: skin picaridin plus clothing permethrin. Scored as a system — it's the setup we actually hike in.

9.0/ 10

Insect Shield Pre-Treated Apparel

Tier 1 · ProvenClothing treatment · Factory-bondedUp to 70 washesLabel + literature

Factory-bonded permethrin rated for up to 70 washes (independent tests show it fading sooner) — the low-maintenance version of clothing treatment, at a per-garment premium. Cost math in our DIY-vs-pretreated guide.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
9.0/ 10

Sawyer Picaridin 20% Lotion

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 20%8–12 hrsLabel + literature

The lotion format trades spray speed for precise, no-drift application — a strong pick for kids' faces, necks, and anyone who hates mist. No affiliate relationship; it's here on merit.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
8.9/ 10

Natrapel Picaridin 20%

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 20%8–12 hrsLabel + literature

A solid Tier-1 picaridin from the Ben's family of brands, commonly in aerosol format — effective, slightly less precise to apply than pump sprays.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
8.4/ 10

3M Ultrathon 34% DEET (controlled-release)

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 34% CR~6–8 hrsLabel + literature

The military-heritage slow-release DEET — the polymer formula stretches protection toward the top of DEET's range. The strongest case left for choosing DEET on performance.

8.1/ 10

Ben's 30% DEET Tick & Insect

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 30%~5–8 hrs★ Field tested

Our budget pick: reliably effective in the field, cheap, everywhere. Costs points on the classic DEET trade-offs — smell, feel, and what it does to plastics and synthetics.

7.9/ 10

OFF! Deep Woods VIII (25% DEET)

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 25%~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

The default drugstore DEET. Works as the label says; scores below 30% formulas on window length and below picaridin on experience.

7.9/ 10

Martin's Permethrin 10% Concentrate

Tier 2 · ConditionalClothing treatment · 10% (dilute to 0.5%)~6 washes (diluted)Label + literature

The bulk option: dilute it yourself and treat a whole family's wardrobe for the price of one ready-made bottle. Conditional only because incorrect dilution is a real failure mode — measure carefully.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
7.8/ 10

Repel Plant-Based Lemon Eucalyptus 30%

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 30% OLE~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

The best-evidenced plant-derived option: EPA-registered, CDC-recognized OLE/PMD. Real protection in a shorter window; CDC says not on children under 3, and most labels agree.

7.7/ 10

Cutter Backwoods (25% DEET)

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 25%~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

Interchangeable with other mid-concentration DEET aerosols — effective, unremarkable, priced accordingly.

7.7/ 10

Murphy's Naturals Lemon Eucalyptus Oil 30%

Tier 1 · ProvenSkin repellent · 30% OLE~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

Registered 30% OLE in a pump spray. Same evidence base as Repel's version; pick by price and scent tolerance. Same under-3 caution: check the label.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
7.4/ 10

OFF! Clean Feel (10% Picaridin)

Tier 2 · ConditionalSkin repellent · 10%~3–5 hrs (ticks)Label + literature

Right active, half the concentration — fine for a short outing, but tick-country days deserve 20%. Conditional tier for the window, not the ingredient.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
7.3/ 10

Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard Plus (IR3535 20%)

Tier 2 · ConditionalSkin repellent · 20%~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

IR3535 is EPA-registered with decades of European use, but published performance varies more by formulation than any other Tier-worthy active — hence the conditional tier.

7.2/ 10

Coleman SkinSmart (IR3535 20%)

Tier 2 · ConditionalSkin repellent · 20%~4–6 hrsLabel + literature

A DEET-free option that's genuinely gear-safe. Same formulation-variability caveat as all IR3535 products.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
6.8/ 10

Repel 100 (98% DEET)

Tier 2 · ConditionalSkin repellent · 98%~6–8 hrs (plateau)Label + literature

Maximum DEET is not maximum protection: efficacy plateaus around 50%, so 98% buys the same window with maximum gear damage and skin load. We earn a commission if you buy it anyway — and we still suggest the 30% instead.

6.3/ 10

OFF! FamilyCare (7% DEET)

Tier 2 · ConditionalSkin repellent · 7%~1.5–2 hrsLabel + literature

Low-DEET formulas trade the smell for a window so short it barely covers a picnic. For ticks, step up or switch actives. (Yes, this is an affiliate link on a 6.3 — the rubric doesn't care what we earn.)

3.9/ 10

Thermacell E-Series (spatial device)

Tier 2 · ConditionalDevice / other · Allethrin cartridgePatio sessionsLabel + literature

A legitimate mosquito tool with a fundamental tick problem: ticks don't fly into the protected air zone — they crawl up from grass onto your legs. For ticks specifically, this isn't protection.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
2.7/ 10

Geraniol ~5% 'natural' sprays (category)

Tier 3 · Not supportedSkin repellent · ~5%MinutesLabel + literature

Sold under EPA's minimum-risk exemption — meaning no efficacy review at all. Independent testing of this category finds protection collapsing within minutes. Not comparable to registered 30% OLE, whatever the shelf tag implies; full reasoning on our methodology page.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
2.4/ 10

Citronella candles (category)

Tier 3 · Not supportedDevice / other · n/aAmbience onlyLabel + literature

Marginal even against mosquitoes in still air; irrelevant to a tick crawling up your boot. Buy them for the mood, not the protection.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
1.6/ 10

Repellent wristbands (category)

Tier 3 · Not supportedDevice / other · variesn/aLabel + literature

Consumer-lab and academic testing agree: protection extends barely beyond the band itself, and a tick at your ankle never notices your wrist. The clearest 'no' in the database.

No affiliate link
scored on merit
No products match those filters — loosen one and try again.

How to read this page: the tiers do the heavy lifting. Tier 1 products are EPA-registered actives at concentrations with real evidence behind them — pick by format and feel. Tier 2 products work in a narrower window than their marketing implies. Tier 3 products are listed so you know why not to buy them — the full reasoning, including why we refuse to score a 5% geraniol spray next to 30% OLE, lives on the methodology page.

Want the deep profile on an active before you pick a product? Ingredient guides: picaridin · DEET · oil of lemon eucalyptus · IR3535 · permethrin. And the duration calculator turns any active + concentration into a protection window.

See the 2026 tick repellent winners →